Independence in Marriage and the Struggle for Differentiation

Independence in Marriage and the Concept of Differentiation

Revised 1/4/20

independence-in-marriageThere is an uneasy tension that exists between a couple’s need for independence in marriage and the desire for intimacy and connection.

There is an innate drive toward being your person while in a marriage. Couples therapists call this drive toward independence in marriage differentiation.

Personal growth of some sort is always happening.

Effective couples therapy balances a couple’s need for both attachment and differentiation while navigating the predictable whirlpools and riptides that threaten to engulf each partner with more of precisely what they don’t want to deal with.

A request for more independence in marriage can be very threatening to some partners, and this struggle often brings them into couples therapy.

“Our self-made crises are custom-tailored, painstakingly crafted, and always fit perfectly.”― David Schnarch.

Differentiation 101

According to Ellyn Bader, differentiation can be defined as the active, ongoing process of defining self, expressing and activating self, revealing self, clarifying boundaries, and managing the anxiety that comes from risking either more intimacy or potential separation.

independence-in marriage

Attachment tends to occur readily at the threshold of commitment, but sustaining it over time is fraught with peril.

In my internship at the Pioneer Valley Center for Couples Therapy, I studied the Bader-Pearson Developmental Model of Couples Therapy.

In the Developmental Model, an effective differentiation stage is considered essential to sustaining vitality in a relationship and allowing for independence in marriage.

But efforts toward differentiation (called “practicing”) are often perceived by the less differentiated partner as a profound threat.

Fear of rejection and abandonment often frustrate these early attempts towards independence in marriage. Often the notion of “I gotta be me” is a dire threat to the partner who prefers to say, “we gotta be we.”

Unfortunately, many relationships sputter and stall at this stage. Many couples slide into an emotional gridlock of hostile dependency or conflict-avoidance. American cultural norms are somewhat opposed to differentiation, as our conception of independence in marriage tends to be misunderstood as diminished intimacy. Early attempts at differentiation can feel like being a circus acrobat without a net!

Differentiation in Couples Therapy… “Not My Circus… Not My Monkeys!”

In the Developmental Model, differentiation is seen as a healthy and necessary process. But what are the therapeutic tasks?
Effective couples therapy will help partners to:

  1. Self-reflect and look inward to identify their thoughts, feelings, wishes, and desires that are independent and distinct from their partner.
  2. differentiationDevelop an increasing skill to express and congruently reveal more of who they are as individuals (without blaming or shaming or being shamed or blamed by their reluctant and uncooperative spouse).

Independence in Marriage requires Separate Awareness

3. Develop an increasing awareness and acceptance of their spouse as a separate and different person from themselves, with their own wishes, needs, and desires.

4. Increase their capacity to carefully listen and respond appropriately to their differences as a couple, while establishing clear and distinct boundaries and areas of independence in marriage.

5. Create a safe and welcoming environment in their relationship that helps to regulate anxiety while managing problems and supporting desired changes.

This process can be messy. The struggle for early differentiation and independence in marriage looks like a three-ring circus. Partners will often release the jungle beasts of their own wants, needs, and desires at the expense of what their partner can readily accept, tolerate, or manage. “Not my circus… not my monkeys,” says the threatened and reluctant partner!

Importance of Differentiation

In a healthy pursuit of independence in marriage, it’s essential for both partners to avoid compromising their bottom-line core values and beliefs. This can be tough to achieve at first.

But to effectively deal with the fundamental 69% of what Gottman calls “unsolvable problems,” a healthy hard-won sense of differentiation will allow a couple to negotiate independence in marriage more effectively by developing resilient ongoing intimacy that respects and manages differences.

“If you can’t regulate your own emotional temperature, you’ll regulate everyone around you to keep yourself comfortable.”― David Schnarch.

Couples vary in their capacity for Differentiation and Independence in Marriage

It is a risky, acquired taste. The lower the level of differentiation, the more likely one partner will tend to:

  1.  Set their spouse up to take the opposite side of ambivalence.
  2.  Pin their unresolved feelings and experiences onto their partner.
  3.  Throw emotional knives of negative transference and projection over and over and over…
  4.  Burn-out quickly during essential conversations.

One caveat.  Attention all narcissists. A stubborn and overbearing stance by one spouse without regard for their partner is not differentiation.

Differentiation begins when a partner can mindfully appreciate two distinct realities at the same time. They see their own reality as well as the reality of their spouse. And doing this means risking “safety” and managing the anxiety of exploring mutual areas of independence in marriage.

Are you struggling because you think your partner wants to run away and join the circus? Take them to a Couples Retreat instead!

Learn More About Healthy Independence in Marriage

Call us for more information at 844-926-8753 to reach Cindy at extension 2.

References:

Bader, E., & Pearson, P. T. (1988). In quest of the mythical mate: A developmental approach to diagnosis and treatment in couples therapy. Brunner/Mazel.

Bowen, M., 1971a. Principles and Techniques of Multiple Family Therapy. In J. Bradt and C. Moynihan, (Eds), Systems Theory, [no publisher stated] Washington, DC.

Bowen, M., 1972. On the Differentiation of Self. First published anonymously in J. Framo, (Ed.), Family Interaction: A Dialogue Between Family Researchers and Family Therapists, NY, Springer: 111-173.

Bowen, M. (1978). Family therapy in clinical practice. New York: Jason Aronson.

Bowen, M, & Kerr, M.E., 1988, ”Family Evaluation: An Approach Based on Bowen Theory, New York: Norton & Co., 1988.

Schnarch, D. M. (1991). Constructing the sexual crucible: An integration of sexual and marital therapy. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.

Schnarch, D., (1997). Passionate Marriage, NY, Norton.

Skowron, E. A. (2000). The role of differentiation of self in marital adjustment. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 47(2), 229–237. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0167.47.2.229

About the Author Daniel Dashnaw

Daniel is a Marriage and Family Therapist. He currently sees couples at Couples Therapy Inc. in Boston, Massachusetts, three seasons in Cummington (at the foothills of the Berkshires...) and in Miami during joint retreats with his wife, Dr. Kathy McMahon. He uses EFT, Gottman Method, Solution-focused and the Developmental Model in his approaches.

1 comment

Comments are closed